First Impressions – Magura MDR-P Brake Rotors

by Brian Mullin on April 16, 2020

magura_mdr_p_rotor

The MDR-P rotors meant there wasn’t any fade, noise, shuddering, or vibration coming from the braking system, just an insane amount of power at your fingertips.

The new Magura eStop brake system is based on their existing four-piston MT5 and two-piston MT4 brakes and is optimized for e-bikes, heavy cargo bikes, and gravity use. In concert with the eStop brakes, they have the new Sport 7.S and 8.S organic brake pads, and the MDR-C and MDR-P rotors, which offer increased braking power and heat resistance. The MDR-C is available in 180mm and 203mm sizes, while the two-piece MDR-P comes in a 203mm and a monster 220mm diameter. We tested a full set of the 203mm MDR-P rotors and Sport 8.S pads on some standard MT5 brakes on an Ibis Ripmo 29er.

For additional information, refer to magura.com.

magura_mdr_p_rotor_parts

MDR-P Rotors

The MDR-P is a two-piece rotor that features a unique Dovetail Interlink technology that interlocks the outer and inner disc rings (think woodworking). When the outer ring expands from heat, the interlocking mechanism provides additional support and strength for the inner ring. This technology means the torque is transmitted over the entire surface of the system instead of just at the rivets, which is the case with a standard floating disc design. The result is increased rigidity and improved heat dissipation, which is much more effective under continuous and heavier braking loads.

This new technology and design mean that the MDR-P is Magura’s most powerful rotor, with reduced vibration, fade resistance, and with a decent weight for a gravity and e-bike oriented disc. It comes in a 203 mm size (216g), and their first-ever 220 mm size (241g), and they both retail for $75 each.

The new 220 mm size rotor generates around 10% more braking force than a 203 mm model and 20% more than a 180 mm model – for the same manual force. The higher mass also reduces the risk of brake fading and reduces brake pad wear by 15%. The temperatures that are critical for the brake pad are reached much later by the MDR-P rotor.

Sport Brake Pads

The new organic Sport brake pads are suitable for any biking purposes but are mainly focused on e-bikes and gravity usage. The pads are positioned between their Comfort and Performance series pads in terms of their braking performance and durability. The Sport pad mixture is optimally adapted to the requirements of e-bikes and the eSTOP brake models, and they offer shorter braking-in time. They come in a single pad 8.S version for $25 (tested), and a double pad 7.S for $30.

magura_mdr_p_rotor_adapters

First Impressions

I have run a 180mm system on my bikes for years, so when installing the 203mm rotors, I had to switch out the current calipers adapters. The front PM7 used their fairly standard QM-26 adapter, but the rear PM6 required a newer version of their QM-7, which has a small dimple to accommodate the wider body of the MT5 4-piston caliper. The MDR-P rotors are pretty hefty, especially compared to the weight weenie Magura Storm SL-2 rotors that I had been running, and they offer a substantially more rigid platform.

magura_mdr_p_rotor_ripmo

The rotors and pads bedded in quickly, but it took some downhill sections for the rotors to come into peak performance. They offered some power right from the get-go, but after a few long steep descents, they jumped to the forefront of stopping power. I’ve used the Magura MT5 and MT7 brakes for a long time, with all sorts of their rotors, but I’ve never felt the kind of power and heat resistance that the MDR-P rotors provided.

There wasn’t any fade, noise, shuddering, or vibration coming from the braking system, just an insane amount of power at your fingertips. I did have to learn to use a lighter touch on the rear brake lever since if you pulled with the usual force, it was easy to lock things up. You could control the bike from any speed; pull in handfuls to come to a complete stop or feather down uber steep technical terrain. After you got used to the amount of power on tap if offered an enjoyable riding experience, where braking was precise and controlled no matter the terrain, conditions, or speeds. It took less effort to pull the brake levers, which decreased hand fatigue, and meant you didn’t have to brake as often. The ability to have such impressive braking power wherever and whenever you need it alters your mindset when riding, and makes braking a background activity.

magura_mdr_p_rotor_mounted

Bottom Line

The innovative dovetail interlocking design between the inner and outer rings of the MDR-P rotors offers increased rigidity, improved heat resistance, and reduced vibration, all of which offer an incredibly powerful and superb performer for a braking system. You can pull in hard for the maximum stoppage, dab as needed to scrub speed, or feather lightly, all with the utmost in precision and control on any terrain.

I am looking forward to continued use of the Magura MDR-P rotors and 8.S pads on my MT5 brakes, especially when I get to toss them on long mountainous descents in the high country of Colorado.

{ 22 comments… read them below or add one }

Dima August 18, 2020 at 8:58 am

Hi Brian,
thank you for your review.
I’m wondering is there any difference between Magura MDR-P 203\220 mm. and Hope floating rotors?

Reply

Brian Mullin August 19, 2020 at 1:02 am

Dima,

Yes, there are some distinct differences in the designs.

While the Hope provides the typical heat dissipation qualities of a floating rotor, the innovative Dovetail Interlink between the inner/outer rings on the Magura offers increased support for the inner when the outer gets hot. This means the torque is applied to the entire surface of the inner ring instead of only at the rivets, which increases rigidity and improves heat dissipation, and it’ss quite notable under heavy braking.

The MTB Lab

Reply

Steve September 16, 2020 at 7:37 pm

Perhaps a stupid question, but are these compatible with Shimano XT brakes?

Reply

Brian Mullin September 16, 2020 at 8:23 pm

Steve,
Magura rotors are 2.0mm thick, while Shimano are 1.8mm, so I doubt they would work properly.
The MTB Lab

Reply

Michael October 2, 2020 at 2:29 pm

Yes it will work. You just have to do a leaver bleed with the new rotors installed. Basically just pump the levers with the shimano bleed cup installed and the leavers rotated until they sit flat until air stops coming out. Same process as fitting new pads. You can run pretty much any rotor with shimano brakes.

Reply

Simon November 28, 2020 at 3:56 pm

When will these be available with the center lock fitting ?

Reply

Brian Mullin November 29, 2020 at 5:35 pm

Not that I am aware of. It was designed just for a 6 bolt system. They’d have to rebuild the entire inner ring so it was just for centerlock. I’ll reach out to my contacts to get the final word on things.
Regards,
The MTB Lab

Reply

Neil February 14, 2021 at 8:41 pm

They released a centerlock MDR-C. Hopefully an MDR-P centerlock is in the works but who knows?

Reply

Brian Mullin February 14, 2021 at 8:52 pm

Yes, we reported that in New Magura Products For 2021. Unknown if they’ll do that for the MDR-P?
The MTB Lab

Reply

Rik June 6, 2021 at 11:33 am

Any news on de MDR-P centerlock design?

Reply

Brian Mullin June 10, 2021 at 11:08 pm

I have not heard any news as yet. With the current huge backlog of parts inventory, I am not sure where it stands as a priority for them?
The MTB Lab

Reply

André September 7, 2021 at 11:50 am

Just e-mailed Magura asking if they have any plans for MDR-P rotors with centerlock.

Brian Mullin September 7, 2021 at 12:07 pm

Rik,
They are doing them!
Here is a picture from Eurobike:

Magura MDR-P CL

The MTB Lab

Reply

Mitch May 23, 2021 at 5:47 pm

Mine have 1000km of shuttling and bike park runs from last season. Bikes just now beginning to sound like a shopping cart. I thought it was chain slap etc which also seemed crazy cause I have a new XO derailleur and a STFU for the chain. Turns out it’s the rear rotor, as soon as you drag brake a teeny bit it goes away. The back rotor is coming off for sure, and getting replaced by a one piece rotor. The front is not as loose yet… But if they both wear in like this, not great in the long run. Power unbelievable, super nice. Noise 0/10….

Reply

Brian Mullin May 23, 2021 at 9:55 pm

I have around 3500-4000km/2000-2500miles on mine and no issues as yet. I have gone through a couple of sets of the green Sport 8.S pads, and I often give them a slight sanding to remove any burring/polish. No problems with the dovetail interlink system being loose. You might ping Magura for assistance on your issue?
Regards,
The MTB Lab.

Reply

Jack pearson June 10, 2021 at 12:09 am

Hi just wanted to know did you have any problems with the mdr disc getting play after 100km just because mine do the 6 bolts are tight the play is coming from the disc where it becomes a to piece design

Reply

Brian Mullin June 10, 2021 at 11:06 pm

Jack,
I’ve had around 2000+ km on them and haven’t had any issues. Suggest you ping Magura for warranty assistance.
The MTB Lab

Reply

Lukas August 10, 2021 at 7:46 pm

Mine are loose after 200km. The effect is rather unnerving, because counter intuitively, the rotors chatter while braking. It seems they’re sensitive to certain resonant frequencies that make them spring back and forth while lightly braking. This often leads to premature rear wheel lock up.

Reply

Brian Mullin January 31, 2022 at 10:20 pm

The MDR-P are still going strong, without any loosening issues.
The MTB Lab

Reply

Shane November 8, 2021 at 2:55 am

I think most floating rotors after a period of time and decent heat cycles get that rattle sound, I had a hope 225 and now a hope 220, both where quite at the start but after some good heat cycles they can rattle. The 220 has just started a little. Still work fine. System weight 135kg + with heavy tyres and 29er on front.

Reply

Brian Mullin January 31, 2022 at 10:16 pm

Shane,
The MDR-P are still going strong, without any loosening issues.
The MTB Lab

Reply

Brian Mullin September 7, 2021 at 11:56 am

André,
They are doing them!
Here is a picture from Eurobike:

Magura MDR-P CL

The MTB Lab

Reply

Leave a Comment

{ 1 trackback }

Previous post:

Next post: